Nasscom pegs IT spending for the US healthcare market at $15 billion, while
Gartner estimates range between $20 and $40 billion. Frost and Sullivan says
that US companies in this segment spent more than $4.2 billion on outsourcing IT
in 2002 and are projected to spend more than $5.2 billion by 2006.
While Indian companies have made some inroads into the US healthcare market,
companies in this segment have traditionally been not too keen on outsourcing IT
requirements, especially to offshore locations. This explains why IBM Global
Services, EDC or Perot Systems in the US are the largest outsourcing providers
for computerized physician order entry (CPOE)—that help reduce medical errors—though
many Indian firms also have CPOE expertise. Nevertheless Indian software majors
and now BPO companies have been focusing on this segment with considerable
success.
Today healthcare contributes between 10% to 25% of the total revenues for
most large Indian software companies.
Need for IT Outsourcing The anticipated rise in IT spending and subsequently outsourcing can be
attributed to a number of factors. Globally, the healthcare sector comprises
payer organizations like health maintenance firms, health insurance companies,
employers, care delivery organizations like hospitals and physician groups and
governmental health organizations.
However, this sector is highly fragmented—in the US alone, there are over
1,500 payer organizations, over 250,000 providers and over 700 government health
agencies.
In addition, even the nature of IT spending in this sector is highly
discretionary—a majority of the healthcare organizations do not have a CTO/CIO
or a centralized purchase department. This has resulted in the absence of
segment-wise uniform applications, where vendors have products targeted at
specific sub-segments. This has resulted in disparate IT systems, where
solutions have been built on a piece-meal basis and from different vendors.
Explains J Rajagopal, director, Global Life Sciences & Healthcare, TCS,
"The fallout of this highly fragmented solutions from a multitude of
vendors compounded with a complex insurance driven health system best
exemplified in the US, has led to the demand for increased IT adoption."
Most healthcare organizations are also looking at ways to cut down on costs by
increasing efficiency and getting legacy applications to interface with new
ones.
The main issue facing the US healthcare system today is the increasing cost
of providing healthcare to its citizens, compounded by the vast numbers of ‘baby
boomers’ growing older thus requiring more and more care.
Healthcare insurers are now also introducing new ideas such as pharmacy
benefit management and disease management programs among others. The providers
are pressurized by the payers into following streamlined processes which focuses
on preventive care and standardized care with a view to reduce healthcare costs.
These programs will heavily depend on the use of IT to provide real time
information access and transcend the boundaries of physical distances. Manpower
shortage, especially in nursing, and the need to get more done with fewer
resources are other major drivers behind the outsourcing push.
BK Kulkarni, DGM-Hospital Information Systems, Siemens Information Systems (SISL)
lists down the most important factors that would drive outsourcing by the US
healthcare IT market in future.
These would include, initiatives to integrate disparate systems; adopt
medical codes and conversion to latest versions (i.e. ICD 10); standardize the
structures of data collection and storage with respect to electronic patient
records, undertaken by the ‘Institute of Medicine’) and finally, establish
real-time data flows among all industry stakeholders.
Success Stories There are already a few successful outsourcing stories—one is the
collaboration between IBM, NYU Medical and Mt. Sinai Hospital; another is the
partnership between New York-Presbyterian and GE Medical.
To take advantage of the opportunities offered by the global healthcare
market, Indian IT vendors should be focusing on providing integrated solutions,
solutions with workflow optimization built in, solutions addressing regulatory
requirements and standards among others. At present, at least 40 Indian tech
firms like Covansys, Silverline, Cognizant, vMoksha, Kshema, Infosys, SISL,
Mascot, Wipro, TCS and others have the know-how to grab a slice of the
healthcare pie in the developed markets.
Golden
Rules for Indian Healthcare Vendors
1.
Understand
the complexity of the US healthcare process and the disparate IT
systems prevalent there; there are about 1,500+ payer organizations,
250,000+ providers and 700+ government health agencies alone in the
US
2.
Focus
initially on key areas like citizens clectronic health Records, CPOE,
data security mechanisms, data warehousing and data mining,
artificial intelligence, point of care solutions; these are the
areas traditionally opening up for outsourcing
3.
Develop
a relationship with a local healthcare vendor (mostly in US); having
nearshore capability through partnership is crucial in this sector
4.
Established
players should look at aspects like administrative billing practices
and improved clinical treatment services through the introduction of
expert information systems, computer-based patient records
5.
Establish
a long term business strategy with the healthcare provider; vertical
oriented sales & marketing team should explain outsourcing
requirements
Meeting
HIPPA requirements
n
Indian
vendors should get their employees/processes HIPPA certified
n
Understand
all HIPPA guidelines as a single non-compliance would draw civil and
criminal penalties
n
Follow
three phases of services—Involve in training and education
services to build awareness; assess operational and technical,
privacy and security services and implementation should be done in
co-ordination with information assurance services, enterprise
application integration services and code remediation services
Indian IT companies, with their emerging IT skills, can offer US healthcare
providers significant savings in certain areas. One of these, believes Dr
Praveen Soti, consultant, healthcare practice, Domain Competency Group, Infosys,
would be administrative billing practices and improved clinical treatment
services through the introduction of expert information systems, computer-based
patient records and other advanced technological solutions.
The other would be leading technology developments such as computer-based
patient records, data warehousing, document imaging, Internet solutions, expert
information systems and tele-medicine. A third, Kulkarni feels, would be
clinical system management, which requires timely information availability,
accuracy of data and synchronization of activities, and facilitating the making
and implementation of life-saving decisions.
For Indian software players catering to the global healthcare market the key
focus areas include citizens electronic health records, CPOE, data security
mechanisms, data warehousing and data mining, artificial intelligence, point of
care solutions besides HIPPA and HL7 (Health Level 7) compliance.
However, the dynamics of the healthcare industry calls for the Indian
software vendors to understand a few specific aspects particular to it. The
first would be to establish a long-term business strategy with the healthcare
provider. Unlike other segments such as CRM, enterprise applications and BPO,
the healthcare software sector is not a fast buck revenue stream. Companies need
to prepare for a long haul as pharmaceutical, diagnostic, medical or healthcare
providers are extremely cautious about outsourcing critical requirements to
third party companies, cautions Kulkarni. The sales and marketing team needs to
work in close tandem with local partners. A vertical-oriented marketing team
will help the company to speed up the sales process.
To
Focus on...
Public
Health Systems: Citizens Electronic Health Records
Artificial
Intelligence
Patient
Safety Tools: CPOE
HIPPA
compliance
Data
warehousing & mining
HL7
compliance
Call
center support for payers
Point-of-care
SOLUTIONS
Another prudent strategy for Indian software companies would be to partner
with local US firms. Though the Indian player might have all the software
expertise, this would help to understand complicated regulations and standards
compliance issues better. One successful example is Covansys partnering with
US-based Qurom Health Resources to explore HIPPA market whereby it offers
services to Qurom’s 300 odd hospital clients. This partnership strategy has
enabled Covansys to complete more than 40 engagements last year.
Even Wipro has a network of relations with global leaders like GE Medical
Systems, Beckman Coulter, Agilent, Fujinon and Cerner. Also, the Wipro Biomed
business is being transferred into Wipro Healthcare and Life Science, to
leverage the existing strong relationship with leading manufacturers of medical
and life science equipment. The new business would also leverage the customer
relationship with the hospitals of Wipro GE Medical Systems, a JV between Wipro
and GE. But, perhaps the most crucial aspect for Indian companies is to
understand compliance with different standards and regulations.
Regulatory Conundrum Regulatory compliance now plays a key role in the global market. The foreign
developed markets are now attempting to put in place standards governing both
the quality as well as the delivery of care. Organizations such as JCAHO (Joint
Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations) measure ‘Providers’
against standards, set by health care professionals. Medical Insurance-driven
HIPAA compliance provides legal acceptance of electronic records and electronic
signatures in the US. HL7 provides the much needed industry standard for
inter-system communication for hospital management systems. Similarly standards
such as ICD, CPT, SNOMED have helped in ensuring medical coding standardization.
To meet regulatory compliance, Indian companies need to get their employees
certified on industry processes. Participation in industry work groups and
forums that are engaged in preparation and perpetuation of these standards will
facilitate quicker implementation of these standards within the company. At
present, though many of the software players are exploring the opportunities
available under the HIPAA program, very few have been able to execute HIPAA
projects. But, compliance with HIPPA guidelines is statutory and non-compliance
would draw civil and criminal penalties.
Indian companies are attempting to address the HIPPA business opportunity
through services covering the three phases of compliance. These include training
and education services to build awareness among various stakeholders. The next
set of services include:
Operational and technical assessment services: This consists of review
of existing business processes and systems to identify areas affected by HIPAA
standards, risks of non-compliance, impacts on operational and business
performance, operational changes for compliance and cost of implementing
changes.
Privacy assessment services: This comprises of review of all areas of
operations and processes to identify privacy-related risks associated with
non-compliance to HIPAA.
Security assessment services: This consists of evaluation of a client’s
systems and policies to ensure they appropriately protect health information, in
accordance with HIPAA requirements and industry best practices.
To push implementation, companies will need to be well-versed in services
like information assurance services (develop a strategy for maintaining the
confidentiality and security of healthcare data); e-commerce management systems
(development of a clearing house infrastructure that would route all
e-transactions in HIPAA-compliant formats); and enterprise application
integration services (integration of existing systems and applications to
process HIPAA-compliant formats).
Implementation would also include code remediation services (to meet HIPPA
requirements) and system replacement services (moving away from legacy systems).
Indian IT companies are in the initial stages of addressing the HIPPA market.
Infosys is planning to offer services on all aspects of HIPPA, besides building
capabilities by recruiting people with domain expertise. Wipro has established a
centre of excellence for HIPPA that evaluates tools and technologies related to
HIPPA, mentors projects, executes proof of concept projects, trains software
engineers and refines HIPPA compliance methodologies. Satyam has established a
new division, recruiting about 150 professionals to address the HIPPA business.
Although the potential is huge, there are many barriers. Given the backlash
outcry and the conservative nature of this industry, Indian companies will have
to re-double their efforts to leverage the benefits of outsourcing.