|
The Saffron Winner
In this cyber race, without an iota of doubt, it was the saffron party that
took the lead over its competitors. Numerous announcements emanated from the IT
cell headquarters in Delhi, like the revamping of its party website (bjp.org)
and the launch of a blog by the prime ministerial candidate LK Advani (blogs.lkadvani.in).
Going by the figures, septuagenarian Advani was the most tech-active leader
right now in India, posting blogs, chatting online, videos, images, and the
works. Not only that there was a user group named Friends of the BJP, that
religiously updated videos and blogs on different websites like YouTube and
Orkut. According to BJP, its website www.lkadvani.com which was launched on
November 8, 2008, was getting 20,000 unique hits everyday during the election
campaign. The site boasted of some 150 archives, 300 photos, and some 700 pages
of textual content.
The Cyber Chanakya for BJP was Prodyut Bora, the convener of the partys IT
cell. The IIM-Ahemedabad alumni had a robust gameplan for the party and tied up
the Advani website with social networking sites like Facebook, Orkut, etc. Even
though the penetration of the Internet is still miniscule, around four crore,
but of these around 60% live in top eight cities impacting around fifty Lok
Sabha seats. So its a medium worth considering. says Bora.
Waking Giant
Congress (I) was initially slow to respond to the online onslaught but soon
it woke up to the challenge. After initiali hibernation, the party portal
projected a clean and revamped look. Biswajeet Prithvi Singh, chairman, computer
department, Congress says, We agave a cleaner and leener look to our
five-year-old website; and there was a team that is updating the content
frequently, he says.
The party launched an online video community on You Tube, and there were
scores and scores of Rahul fanclubs on Facebook and Orkut. Yet, the party never
launched an individual blog or website for its biggest face in the election,
Rahul Gandhi. We are not going to have any individualistic website, emphasised
Singh.
And the Followers
So, where were the rest of the political parties when it came to cyberspace,
one might wonder. Another technocrat who expectedly did well was Chandrababu
Naidu and his Telugu Desam Party. In fact, there was one party website for the
United Kingdom based non-resident Indians (which has an image of Naidu morphed
onto a photograph of Obama with the White House in the background). The website
also had an online contribution campaign wherein the people are asked to
contribute through credit card, Internet enabled bank account, PayMate (Mobile
payment), ITZ cash cards, debit cards, etc.
The comrades too belatedlywoke up to the power of the web. They launched a
video community on YouTube to spread their message; and their website (cpim.org)
was updated regularly. But even so there is still some amount of scepticism in
the minds of the comrades when it comes to using technology. In a poor land
like ours, canvassing and public meetings will be the mainstay for political
parties. Such online campaigns can be a successful model for the US where
Internet penetration is 100%; I have my doubts about India, says Prasanjeet
Bose, convenor, research unit, CPM.
The comrades too belatedlywoke up to the power of the web. They launched a
video community on YouTube to spread their message; and their website (cpim.org)
was updated regularly. But even so there is still some amount of scepticism in
the minds of the comrades when it comes to using technology. In a poor land
like ours, canvassing and public meetings will be the mainstay for political
parties. Such online campaigns can be a successful model for the US where
Internet penetration is 100%; I have my doubts about India, says Prasanjeet
Bose, convenor, research unit, CPM.
|
Disclosure of Information:
Snapshots |
- Reiterating the primacy of suo moto
dislosures: It is a matter of great concern that even after three years of
implementation, the RTI Act and the expiry of 120 days set by the Act for
public authorities to comply with suo moto provisions, the aggregate
national average degree of compliance is a mere 33%
- Failure to leverage technology: The
fancied e-governance story in India reveals many shortcomings when it
comes to citizen-centric measures like disclosing basic and essential
information. The gross under-utilization of websites as a means to publish
basic information to citizens is a major disappointment
- Only half the battle won: The pointers
emerging from this pioneering evaluation show that getting the RTI Act
legislated is only half the battle. The struggle for effective
implementation is long from over
- Learning from the leaders: There is much
to learn from the examples of Nagaland, Delhi and Bihar in making the RTI
provisions citizen centric. Be it the commitment of top political
leadership or conscious efforts to leverage ICTs to make the working of
the administration transparent, there is much to learn and implement
- Incentivizing proactive disclosure: The
abysmal compliance to the statutory provision of suo moto disclosures
raises a genuine need to penalize the laggards. Necessary policy
directives may be enforced to deter such non-compliances in the future.
|
Beyond that, there was not much action in terms of political parties. Though
prime ministerial candidate, Mayawati was supposedly going to launch her own
blog , the party website itself (bahujansamajp.com) was not updated for a long
long time. The last time it was done was in August 2008. Samajwadi Party (samajwadipartyindia.com)
and RJD also seem to be oblivious to the power of the Internet, having
rudimentary websites put up. That is much the case with the rest of the regional
parties like Shiv Sena, NCP, etc. In fact, firebrand Mamata Banerjees website (trinamoolcongress.com)
did not work at all.
In a way, all major political parties tried to reach mass and class, and the
use of the online medium was an inseparable part of their election campaign this
year. The biggest motivator was the cost factor. It made good sense as well,
says Mrutunjoy Mishra, co-founder, Juxtconsult.com adding, By spending some Rs
3-4 lakh, one can get around 4 mn impressions which is far cheaper when compared
to other media channels like television or outdoor.
In Conclusion
What these elections taught was that there are a lot of advantages that the
parties can draw from the Internet. For instance, the election code of conduct
is still not clear, on how the promotion on the Internet can be effected. For
instance, all campaigning in other mediums has to end twenty-four hours before
the polling, but candidates can still reach out to their communities through
online websites even at the last minute. This advantage can be exploited by the
parties in future till there is an explicit direction given by the Election
Commission.
But whether this entire web push resulted in gains on the ground is still
debatable. It did work in the US, but whether it really worked in India this
time is still a far-fetched question? The Obama template had little relevance to
the bulk of the 400mn voters that actually elected 543 MPs in India on the basis
of caste, creed and Rs 2 per kg rice promises. Nonetheless, this was a
preliminary round and surely by 2014, the Internet will be a powerful medium
without doubt. As more and more Indians log on to the Internet it is inevitable.
So while Maos gunpowder brought revolutions and power till some decades back;
it will be copper in the future. And this years election might just give an
indication of the same.
Shashwat DC
shashwatc@cybermedia.co.in
Page(s) 1 2
|