Amidst all the brouhaha about the backlash against India as an offshore
outsourcing destination, some succor was recently provided to the embattled
Indian BPO and IT services community. It came in the form of AT Kearney’s 2004
Offshore Location Attractiveness Index that ranked India as the No.1 global
outsourcing destination ahead of China, that ranked second. Asian powerhouses
like Malaysia, Singapore and Philippines also figured in the Top 10 club.
The study analyzed 25 countries against 39 measurements in three categories.
Financial factors made up for 40% of the index weightage, people skills and
availability contributed 30% and local business environments accounted for the
remaining 30%. Not surprisingly, India’s status as the leader of the pack is
bolstered by its cost advantages, and more significantly by the depth and range
of offshoring experience and people skills—advantages which have been tom-tommed
about for years both by enterprises who outsource to India as well as the Indian
BPO/IT services players.
Rather than basking in the glory, the report offers enough indications about
which the Indian industry should take note off immediately if they want to
maintain the competitive advantage. India might have pipped China to the post
for the time being, thanks to its mature market and quality of IT education and
management, but it is no more a secret that China is working on a war footing
for a long time now to nullify India’s advantage. Add to that, China’s cost
advantages and large educated labor pool plus cultural and language synergies is
helping it grow as an offshore destination for Japanese and Korean companies.
This, unfortunately, is one important fact most of the Indian lobbyists tend to
overlook—while India might continue to have the English advantage for some
more time, Japan and Korea together contribute close to 20% of the global
outsourcing pie.
Not only China, it is time for India to wake up to threats from other
unexpected quarters too. India should seriously look at competition not only
from traditional Asian rivals like Philipines and Malaysia (which are in the Top
10 club), but from East European and Latin American countries like Czech
Republic, Poland, Hungary, Brazil and Chile.
Add to this the fact that developed countries like Singapore, Canada and New
Zealand also score heavily on fronts like the business environment index (much
ahead of India) thanks to aggressive government promotions, excellent education
and infrastructure, high social and political stability and strong IPR
protection.